This book sets out the necessary processes and challenges involved in
modeling student thinking, understanding and learning. The chapters look
at the centrality of models for knowledge claims in science education
and explore the modeling of mental processes, knowledge, cognitive
development and conceptual learning. The conclusion outlines significant
implications for science teachers and those researching in this field.
This highly useful work provides models of scientific thinking from
different field and analyses the processes by which we can arrive at
claims about the minds of others. The author highlights the logical
impossibility of ever knowing for sure what someone else knows,
understands or thinks, and makes the case that researchers in science
education need to be much more explicit about the extent to which
research onto learners' ideas in science is necessarily a process of
developing models.
Through this book we learn that research reports should acknowledge the
role of modeling and avoid making claims that are much less tentative
than is justified as this can lead to misleading and sometimes contrary
findings in the literature. In everyday life we commonly take it for
granted that finding out what another knows or thinks is a relatively
trivial or straightforward process. We come to take the 'mental
register' (the way we talk about the 'contents' of minds) for granted
and so teachers and researchers may readily underestimate the challenges
involved in their work.